A newsletter operator added nearly 5,000 subscribers organically from Reddit using two simple strategies. His secret? Strategic comments that piggyback on trending posts, providing detailed value before softly mentioning his newsletter. One well-placed comment responding to the top comment on a trending post brought him 100+ subscribers. His second newsletter got 200 subscribers in just 24 hours using the same playbook.
📍 What It Is
The Strategic Commenting Method: Finding trending posts in relevant subreddits, responding to top comments with substantial value (100+ words), and passively mentioning your newsletter as a helpful resource—not a promotion.
🎯 Why It Works
Visibility optimization - Responding to top comments puts you in front of thousands who are already engaged
Higher conversion than posts - People reading comments are more engaged than those scrolling past posts
Piggyback momentum - You leverage the traction another post is already getting
Lower risk than posting - Comments require less effort and face less scrutiny than promotional posts
Non-promotional framing - Mentioning your newsletter as a resource (not a pitch) bypasses spam filters
Reddit users scroll immediately to comments after reading posts. By being the top reply to the top comment, you're guaranteed visibility without needing your own post to go viral.
⚙️ How It Works
Strategy 1: Strategic Commenting (Highest ROI)
Find trending posts in your niche subreddits - Look for posts currently trending (#1-5 position) in subreddits like r/entrepreneur, r/SaaS, r/marketing, or whatever matches your newsletter topic. Trending posts get continuous traffic for hours.
Identify the top comment - Read the highest-upvoted comment. Can you add value to that discussion? Do you have a relevant perspective, data, or insight that builds on what they said?
Write a detailed, value-packed response - Minimum 100 words. Provide genuine insight, personal experience, or helpful perspective. Don't just agree—add something new to the conversation. Make it conversational and authentic.
Add a passive newsletter plug - At the very end, mention your newsletter like you're recommending it to a friend: "I actually write about this topic weekly in my newsletter if you want to dive deeper" or "This is exactly what I cover in [newsletter name]—feel free to check it out."
Respond early for maximum visibility - The first 1-2 hours after a post starts trending are critical. Your comment needs to gain traction before the post loses momentum.
The Formula:
Trending post + top comment + your valuable addition (100+ words) + passive newsletter mention = 100+ subscribers
Strategy 2: Creating Posts (Secondary Strategy)
Structure posts with ChatGPT help - Use ChatGPT to break down complex topics into digestible sections:
"What happened, explain like I'm in 10th grade"
"What are the implications?"
"What should we take away from this?"
Create conversational, captivating titles - Make people want to click and comment. Optimize for engagement, not perfection.
Plug newsletter strategically - Include hyperlink naturally within the post (e.g., "I break this down further right here") rather than at the end where it feels promotional.
Cover who, what, when, where, why, how - Complete information sparks discussion, which feeds the algorithm and pushes your post higher.
Expected Results:
#1 posts: 50+ subscribers in 12-24 hours (achievable 33% of the time with practice)
Strategic comments: 100+ subscribers per well-placed comment
New newsletter launch: 200 subscribers in 24 hours using these tactics
Pro Tips:
Only plug your newsletter ONCE per comment or post
Make it sound like a friend's recommendation, not an ad
Compare your newsletter to alternatives if relevant (makes it feel objective)
Focus on subreddits where your target readers already congregate
Reddit users value authenticity—any hint of "shill" behavior gets flagged immediately
Critical Rules:
Provide substantial value first, promotion second
Never start with your newsletter—earn the right to mention it
If it feels like an ad, rewrite it to feel like advice
🏆 Real Example
Newsletter Operator: Eric Lam
Results: 5,500+ subscribers grown exclusively through Reddit
Example 1 - Strategic Comment:
Found trending post at #1 in r/entrepreneur
Responded to the top comment with detailed perspective
His comment became the top reply (highly visible)
Added passive newsletter plug at the end
Result: 100+ newsletter signups from one comment
Example 2 - Comparative Mention:
Compared his free newsletter to a paid competitor
Linked to both options (appeared objective, not promotional)
Made his newsletter look like the obvious choice
Result: High conversion without seeming like a sales pitch
Example 3 - Post Strategy:
Created #1 post in target subreddit
Used ChatGPT to structure content clearly
Embedded newsletter link naturally in post body
Result: 50+ subscribers in 24 hours
Second Newsletter Launch:
Applied same strategies to brand new newsletter
Result: 200 subscribers in first 24 hours
Key insights:
Commenting converts better than posting (higher engagement, lower effort)
Piggybacking on trending posts is underrated—most people don't do this thoughtfully
100-word minimum ensures you're providing real value, not just dropping links
Passive framing ("if you want to learn more") works better than direct promotion
Responding to top comments de-risks time investment—you know the post is already trending
Success Rate:
Hits #1 position approximately 33% of the time with posts
Nearly 100% visibility when responding to top comments on trending posts
💡 Your Turn Pick one topic you want to own in AI search. Run it through ChatGPT and Perplexity this week to see who's currently getting cited.
Reply with what you discovered—the most surprising competitive insight gets featured Friday!
🔓 Want All 1,000 Strategies? Get instant access to our complete Traffic Strategies vault → [Link]